The optional theme this week was “defective,” and the posts that I read were anything but defective!
Lori Ann Wegner of The Buttermaker and the Midwife posted “Herman Loock Was Too Deaf for the Draft.” Cheri Hudson Passey of Carolina Girl Genealogy wrote “Defective Ancestors — the Dorritys.” She also found some interesting discrepancies among the records. Cheryl Biermann Hartley of My Search for the Past wrote about her ancestor “Nettie Walton – a Documented Idiot.”
On a personal note, as the mother of a Deaf son, I’d like to thank everyone, first, for tackling this subject and, second, for doing so with such compassion.
Your Turn
Who did you write about for Week 33 (whether or not you used the optional theme)? Leave a comment with a link below. Take a few moments to look at the posts from Week 32. I continue to be amazed at the writing we see every week.
Upcoming Optional Themes
- Week 34 (August 20-26) – Non-Population
- Week 35 (August 27 – September 2) – School Days
A bit of a delay with the September themes. Moving my daughter back to college too more time than I planned. (You’d think after doing this 3 times before that I’d know it always takes longer than planned!)
I wrote about a family dependent on each other – is this defection from the theme a delinquency on my part?
52 Ancestors: #33 SCHERFF-CLEMENS, A Family Dependent on Each Other
by Cathy Meder-Dempsey at Opening Doors in Brick Walls
I see what you did there 😉
I’m going to make it to the end of the using the themes! I hadn’t planned to but each time they worked it spurned me on to do the next and the next….
* end of the year
Off topic from suggestion today – so I wrote about one of my puzzles:
Almira (Perkins?) wife of Timothy Holt
https://kessgen.wordpress.com/2015/08/08/52-ancestors-2015-33-almira-wife-of-timothy-holt/
Thank you, Amy, for posing this theme. Without it, I probably would never have worked up the courage to write about uncovering the secrecy surrounding my great grandmother Jorgena Torkelson’s institutionalization in a home for the “Insane”.
http://victoriajosfamilystories.blogspot.ca/2015/08/jorgena-torkelson-1862-1912-52.html
Thank you for sharing her story, Joanne. I left a couple of suggestions on your post for records you might want to look for. (You’ve probably already tried, but just in case…)
WILLEY–Charlotta Ludlow “Lottie” Willey–What Happened to You? This is about my great great aunt, who spent over 25 years in the State Asylum #3 in Nevada, Missouri. Why is a mystery,
http://ancestorsiwishiknew.blogspot.com/2015/08/68-charlotta-ludlow-lottie-willey-what.html
John Conway SHIFLETT
http://jollettetc.blogspot.com/2015/08/52-ancestors-disabled-but-not-defective.html
Ida SCHNEITER (STUCKY) was fortunate not to have any defects to list on the census, nor did any of her many siblings or babies–although I suspect in some small, close communities, where the census taker was a member of the community, there may have been blank spaces that were supposed to be filled in–don’t you?
So I focused on the many babies in the household of Ida, one of which was her first grand daughter, my Husband’s mother.
http://ancestorsinaprons.com/2015/08/52-ancestors-ida-schneiter-babies/
I stuck with my own family lines, and the only person who ‘qualified’ in any way, was his 2nd wife. A big mystery. Huge age difference, married very shortly after his 1st wife died… and then the 2nd wife had ‘something’ catastrophic happen to be labelled as “idiotic” on the Census. I wish I knew more about her, and about their relationship…
http://twigsandtrees.blogspot.ca/2015/08/52-ancestors-52-themes-no33-emily-2nd.html
Joseph Dudley Jr. – no. 49 (week 33): his life ended tragically
http://denise-livinginthepast.blogspot.com/2015/08/52-ancestors-no-49-joseph-dudley-jr.html
COATES – Sallie, Sarah or Mary maybe Coates (c1740-1782/1878), Mystery Wives of the Reverend George McNiel
http://dna-explained.com/2015/08/16/sallie-sarah-or-mary-maybe-coates-c1740-17821787-mystery-wives-of-the-reverend-george-mcniel-52-ancestors-85/
I haven’t found anyone on these schedules (yet). I decided that I would continue with the “32” theme, since I’ve been working on writing about my 3rd great grandparents anyway.
Elizabeth Sewall WILLIS Wells (1820-1900) for whom I have an 1882 passport application. I love what you can find there!
http://frommainetokentucky.blogspot.com/2015/08/third-great-grandmother-elizabeth.html
GOMBERT – Ulysses S. Gombert (1868-1904), Carbon County, Pennsylvania.
WINTERS – Week 33 “Defective, Dependent, and Delinquent”: Hugh Winters
http://so-many-ancestors.blogspot.com/2015/08/52-ancestors-week-33-defective.html
My 4th-great-grandfather Hugh Winters was listed as blind, but most of the census questions were not answered. I speculated on what the answers might have been.
My 3x great grandfather’s little sister was listed as dumb of epileptic fits in the 1860 census.
https://everyleafhasastory.wordpress.com/2015/08/20/elizabeth-52-ancestors-challenge-2015-week-33/
Henry Sargent died 1885 and his health issues were listed on the 1880 census.
http://timelinesandstories.blogspot.com/2015/08/52-weeks-defective-dependent-deliquent.html
In the 1841 Scottish census my 3rd great-grand uncle was unfortunately described.
http://ancestorchaser.blogspot.com.au/2015/08/52-ancestors-week-33-alexander-forsyth.html
I didn’t follow the theme this week. I’m sure I have defective ancestors somewhere, as the odds are in favor of it, but I couldn’t find any. Instead, I chose to write about an ancestor whose middle name has always been a point of interest for me.
LINDLEY, Mary L.
http://wiseheartjourney.com/2015/08/18/mary-l-lindley-what-does-the-l-stand-for/
Feldbusch, Friedrich Wilhelm, who has been a tramp
http://vorfahrensucher.de/friedrich-wilhelm-feldbusch/
I haven’t found any ancestors, direct or collateral, in these schedules. I do have a great-grandmother who was institutionalized in the 20th century, but I don’t know enough of her story to write something. I chose to write about a more distant ancestor who would have been on these census schedules if they existed during her lifetime.
DUTCH, Grace (Pratt) – her case would be considered elder abuse in today’s society. http://mymaineancestry.blogspot.com/2015/08/petition-of-poor-distressed-widow-52.html
Abner BEARD
Blind Since Birth
Married, had children and worked for a living.
http://tangledrootsandtrees.blogspot.com/2015/08/52-ancestors-33-blind-since-birth.html?m=1
This week I wrote about the sad story of my g-g-grandfather who ended up homeless and died in the Stirling Combination Poorhouse
HUNTER, Alexander – from Stirling and Glasgow Scotland
http://martinewsancestors.blogspot.com/2015/08/52ancestors-week-33-defective-dependent.html
WALTON
Amy,
Thanks for mentioning my post, “Nettie Walton – A Documented Idiot.” I can only imagine how bewildered Nettie must have been when she was placed in the county home after the death of her parents. I am so glad that her sister finally took her in!
http://wp.me/p4ioO6-gt
I wrote about my step-father’s great grandfather, because it’s almost the anniversary of his birthday and I found his 1st great grandfather in the 1890 Veteran’s Census!
Charles Louis Tavernier Sr of Belgium
http://gatheringbranches.blogspot.com/2015/08/52-ancestors-week-33-charles-louis.html
I’ve just joined the challenge and for week 34 Non population theme I wrote about the information I discovered about my great grandfather in his military record
http://myhistorypath.blogspot.com.au/
Welcome, Elizabeth! I’ve added your blog to the list of those participating. I love the name, by the way! History is definitely a series of paths!
COMPTON, Frances Louisa “Fanny” was my maternal great-great-aunt who spent the last 7 years of her life in an insane asylum in New Westminster BC.
LEYH, Edward was my maternal grandfather. He was not “Defective, Dependent, and Delinquent” but someone I depended on greatly. I’m so far behind so trying to catch up today.
https://dawnsfamilyhistory.wordpress.com/2015/09/12/52-week-challenge-week-33-edward-leyh-1923-2008/
STEPHENS, WILSON – This week I chose to feature my 3rd Great Grandmother, Elizabeth (Stephens) Wilson. She is listed as “blind” in the 1850 & 1860 census. My Pinterest Board address here:
https://www.pinterest.com/pattidi/52-ancestors-on-pinterest/
HAND, SAMUEL – My ancestor was a Loyalist who defected to Canada during the American Revolution.
http://exm.nr/1KDC7Fr